Head-to-head · 2026
Middlebury College vs Saint Michael's College
Compare average net price ($31,483 at Middlebury College; $25,239 at Saint Michael's College), ROI score (6.06 vs 6.07), ten-year median earnings ($76,310 vs $61,317), and admissions selectivity (10.8% acceptance at Middlebury College; 84.5% at Saint Michael's College) using federal College Scorecard data. Middlebury College has a 5-2 metric-level edge. The ROI scores are close, so aid letters, program fit, graduation rate and debt should decide the better fit.
Face to face
Metric-by-metric comparison
9 metrics, side by side. A colored cell marks a metric-level advantage. Green = lower-is-better, violet = higher-is-better.
| Metric | Middlebury College | Saint Michael's College |
|---|---|---|
| ROI score | 6.06 | 6.07 ✓ |
| Avg net price | $31,483 | $25,239 ✓ |
| Median earnings (10y) | $76,310 ✓ | $61,317 |
| Acceptance rate | 10.8% ✓ | 84.5% |
| Graduation rate | 91.4% ✓ | 72.8% |
| Median debt | $13,857 ✓ | $26,922 |
| Enrollment | 2,738 | 1,092 |
| Ownership | Private Non-Profit | Private Non-Profit |
| Avg SAT | 1508 ✓ | 1245 |
| Metric advantages | 5 | 2 |
Value readout
Where each school has the edge
Middlebury College costs $6,244 more per year than Saint Michael's College ($31,483 vs $25,239). Middlebury College graduates report $14,993 higher median earnings after ten years ($76,310 vs $61,317). On EduGradify's model that puts Saint Michael's College ahead on projected ROI (6.07 vs 6.06, exceptional investment).
The more affordable option (Saint Michael's College) also posts the better return, making it the lower-risk pick on cost alone. On admissions, Middlebury College is highly competitive at 10.8% acceptance versus 84.5% (accessible) at Saint Michael's College.
Frequently asked
Middlebury College vs Saint Michael's College, answered
5 of the most common questions, with real numbers from federal data.
Is Middlebury College or Saint Michael's College the better value?
Saint Michael's College has the higher EduGradify ROI score (6.07 vs 6.06), meaning its ten-year earnings go further against its net price.
Which school costs less after aid?
Saint Michael's College is cheaper — average net price $25,239 per year vs $31,483 at Middlebury College. The annual difference of $6,244 adds up to about $24,976 over four years.
Which school reports higher earnings?
Middlebury College reports higher median earnings ten years after entry: $76,310 vs $61,317 at Saint Michael's College. The annual gap in the federal data is $14,993.
Which school is harder to get into?
Middlebury College is more selective at 10.8% acceptance vs 84.5% at Saint Michael's College.
What should I compare beyond ROI?
Use the ROI score as a value screen, then compare aid letters, program fit, graduation rate, location, campus size, and debt. Middlebury College reports a C value grade; Saint Michael's College reports C.